In my opinion, there are a great deal of advantages that can be gained by being well versed in rhetorical analysis. First off, it offers you an opportunity to review something that you may or may not agree with, and look at it under a magnifying glass. While analyzing a piece, not only are you able to evaluate how effective it is as a piece of rhetoric, but you’re also able to take it in and form your own opinion on the topic that they are presenting to you.
Another advantage to analyzing other people’s rhetorical pieces, is that it prepares you to pick apart other people’s arguments. Once you’ve practiced picking apart someone’s statement, it will be much easier for you to find the errors in someone else’s argument after practicing it a few times. Lets say that you are in a debate with a friend of yours, after the things that we’ve practiced, if they state a logical fallacy, you will be able to more efficiently pick through the contradiction, and form a witty response that will support your own cause, or help them strengthen their own cause. Also, you can always make you and your point sound more well founded, if you say something to the effect of, “You sir, are using scare tactics to excel your views.” Just simply being able to practice to find out what is wrong with a written piece, helps one find out what is wrong, on the spot, with what is coming out of someone’s mouth, while preparing their own rhetorical appeal.
Analyzation of another’s rhetoric can also make you a better rhetorician yourself. As is true with any learned skill, not only does practice make perfect, but so does watching the winners and losers of that skill, learning from their trials and tribulations. So to with rhetoric, by judging the strengths and weaknesses of someone else’s piece, so to are you able to better find the weaknesses in your own writing, and play off of the strengths that you already possess. By seeing what someone does wrong, or by what someone does right, you can keep these facts in mind when you are composing your own piece.
We as people, don’t just evaluate rhetoric when we are given an assignment by a teacher, we are always evaluating other people’s statements and opinions on a daily basis. It seems that no matter where we are, or what we are doing, we are never to far from experiencing a rhetorical appeal from someone. Whether it be from a politician in front of an audience of hundreds of thousands of supporters and those who are in opposition of their view, or just ourselves, B.S.ing with that guy who doesn’t shut up at the Kwik Trip down the street, rhetoric is everywhere. Being more familiar with the various aspects of rhetoric helps us formulate, as well as evaluate, other people’s appeals.
Tuesday, October 07, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
I agree with you that while rhetorically analyzing other people's arguments we are able to organize our thoughts better. Back in high school I was a part of Model UN (for a very short time, but whatever,) and we also had a few mock trials in class and reflecting back into my memories analyzing other people's rhetoric as well as their viewpoints always helped me form and strengthen my ideas better.
Also, just commenting on rhetorical analysis itself, there are always people who are so much more articulate than other ordinary people that even if they talk about the same thing it sounds so much more compelling and reasonable. Rhetorical analysis of course enables us to dissect these arguments and helps us to find out what really is underneath the oh so very articulate argument. But on the other hand, I couldn't help but think, would we be able to completely disregard one's skill of delivery and word choice when we're able to analyze the true rhetoric?
Post a Comment